The term powerpointless refers using PowerPoint without a purpose aka there is no point. This can happen when a teacher assigns students to create a PowerPoint without necessary guidelines to promote learning. An electronic tool such as PowerPoint CAN enhance a student’s ability to explore, reason, communicate and persuade if combined strategically with the best of classic tools and techniques. However, if we use too much technology and encourage student’s growth of mentalsoftness by allowing simply cutting and pasting information into a PowerPoint rather than engaging them in thoughtful research, we are allowing students to create powerpointless assignments. From this they will gain little knowledge by mindlessly cutting and pasting information they may not even read.
I am sure we have all seen those powerpointless presentations, and maybe even created them before. Those are the ones when the presenter thoughtlessly reads from each slide, word for word, without adding any further knowledge. The student says only the bullet points and cannot look away from the slides when presenting. Then at the end of the presentation is unable to answer questions posed from the audience or teacher. Who gained any knowledge from this? The presenter? The other students in the class? NO! No one did! It is our responsibility as teachers to NOT allow this to happen by creating assignments that do NOT encourage this type of mindless work.
If we want students to create quality work then we must provide them with excellent examples to show them their potential. A student also needs to be given guidelines so they know what the expectations are that need to be met. Setting up the guidelines for a student is really an area that you can encourage students to do original work, require them to gain thorough subject knowledge and make sure they fulfill all the other objectives you want to come from this project.
As a teacher we must emphasize ideas and logic. A PowerPoint presentation should have smooth transitions and some media images; however, it is more important for it to contain ideas and logic. It is important that students in the audience to follow what the presenter is saying and not getting interrupted by lots of fancy transitions. A PowerPoint presentation should really include more time researching (about 80%) and much less time actually presenting (20%). It is most important that the student has done solid research and gained background knowledge. One way to encourage this is to require students to create a research log in which the list the times and activities when they have done research.
Another way we can teach students to learn and think thoughtfully with PowerPoint is by assigning them topics that maintain depth and complexity. The more depth and complexity an assignment has the more a student will have to delve into their research and think about the subject. A great way to use PowerPoint is giving them a topic that includes two solutions to a problem in which they have to decide on which topic they believe will be the best solution. This forces them to do research and critically think about the material. A project like this that causes thoughtful reflection rather than factual regurgitation will better prepare them for their future.
Your connection to how using this tool can motivate deeper research and higher learning skills in synthesizing pertinent information in a presentation as a demonstration of learning outcomes is excellent. You did a great job of making these connections. Your explanation adds power to the concept of using PowerPoint as a tool. I also liked the emphases you put on the responsibility of the teacher to ensure that this type of project is NOT a mindless waste of time and energy.
ReplyDeleteI agree with all of your points. Creating an environment where students focus on learning and teaching is the best when using powerpoints.
ReplyDeleteI agree, PowerPoints without a point are horrible. Thanks for emphasizing the importance of the role that a teacher has in making sure that the students understand what an effective PowerPoint should look like. I also think the point you made about choosing in depth topics. It's true!
ReplyDeleteThat's a great point that knowledge of a topic and PowerPoint savvy are moot if the students don't have an interesting or deep topic. Every aspect of a technology-based assignment has to be well-thought out in order to be effective. Nice work!
ReplyDelete